If you're lucky enough to be the recipient of a piece of vintage engagement or wedding jewelry that's been passed down for generations, you may have a tough time even guessing at the value of this piece. Even if you have no plans to sell it, having an accurate appraisal on hand can make it far easier to insure this ring against theft or damage. What makes appraising vintage jewelry different, and what are your best options for seeking an appraisal of a one-of-a-kind vintage ring?

Why Is Appraising Vintage Jewelry More Challenging?

Appraising mass-produced pieces still requires the appraiser to exercise some discretion. However, since it's easier to find both the original sales price and the current going rate for "comps" (or comparable pieces), it's usually possible to obtain an accurate appraisal amount that's tailored to the ring's condition, the area of the country in which you live, and the cost of replacement.

However, many vintage rings are literally one-of-a-kind, which can make it tough to find pieces that are comparable in every respect (or even most respects). 

Appraisers also must analyze the effect of factors like stone size, clarity, and setting. For example, a vintage ring that features a half-carat diamond with extremely high clarity may be worth more than a vintage ring that has a lower-quality one-carat diamond. 

Finally, appraisers will need to factor in the "intangibles." Was this ring once worn by a celebrity or Nobel Prize winner? Was it hidden in a secret ship compartment and transported to the U.S. during World War II? While the fact that your grandmother wore this ring won't imbue it with any special value to others, if your grandmother was given this ring by a member of the Getty family, it might prove quite valuable.

What Should You Do to Have Your Vintage Ring Appraised?

When you're seeking out a non-traditional appraisal, it's a good idea to go with a shop that has specific experience in vintage jewelry. Not only do these appraisers see more pieces that are similar to yours (and, therefore, have a better starting idea of what they might be worth), but they also have invaluable connections in the industry that can help them get the most accurate comps. 

If you're not satisfied with your initial appraisal amount, don't be afraid to ask for a second opinion. A quality appraiser will be willing to provide you with some names of others who can value your ring to reveal whether the first appraisal is in the right ballpark.

To learn more, contact a jewelry appraisal professional.

Share